2Dig Plain comparisons of crane signalling and jobsite communication tools

How to assess crane signal trainees passing calls clearly

A practical guide for crane signal trainers to prepare a call assessment, run the drill, compare tool options and avoid common scoring mistakes.

By 2Dig ยท

2Dig is published by the makers of OperatorLink, which is compared here alongside other tools.

Write down the calls used on site, run every trainee through the same drill on two phones, and score the calls against the same clear criteria. In a phone browser session, button presses, chat and voice pass between phones. [1] STOP releases every held direction on every phone and shows a full-screen alert to everyone else. [1] HOLD and SLOW stay on for everyone in the jobsite and are cleared when the last person leaves. [1] On Android browsers, signals such as STOP make the phone buzz, while iPhone Safari ignores the buzz. [1] A jobsite with nobody in it is wiped after 3 idle hours. [1]

OptionWhat it doesFeeCard fee
OperatorLinkShows STOP, HOLD and SLOW to the crew and passes button presses, chat and voice between phones in a browser [1]Currently free to use, no paid plan built yet [1]not published
Phone video call appnot publishednot publishednot published
Two-way radionot publishednot publishednot published

What you need before you start

Write the call list before the first trainee arrives: the words the trainee must send and the reply the crew must give back, so every trainee is scored against the same thing.

Have two phones with working browsers ready so the trainee can send calls and the trainer can observe what appears on the other phone. Button presses, chat and voice pass between phones in a browser. [1]

Decide who starts the jobsite, because that person shares a link or QR code and everybody else joins from it. [1] For the assessment, consider letting the trainee start it and share the link or QR code with the trainer.

Keep one score sheet per trainee, with a column for the call made, a column for what the other phone received, and a column for the time between the two. Keep a second listener if the crew on site will hear the same calls, because the trainee has to be clear to them as well.

Before the first drill, the page can be added to the phone's home screen as a standalone app. [1]

Check what each phone does with an alert before scoring starts, because on Android browsers signals such as STOP make the phone buzz, and iPhone Safari ignores the buzz. [1]

A jobsite with nobody in it is wiped after 3 idle hours, so a session left overnight will not be there for the morning group. [1]

Step by step

  1. Set the call list in the order the calls come up in a lift, and mark which calls must be repeated back by the crew before the load moves.
  1. Open the session on the trainee's phone in a browser, with no app install needed, and open the same session on the second phone that stands in for the crew. [1]
  1. Have the person starting the jobsite share the link or QR code, then join the session from the second phone. [1]
  1. Run the short calls first. One-tap radio-style calls such as Go Ahead, Copy That and All Clear are sent as chat messages. [1] Compare the trainee's calls with the agreed assessment criteria using observations supported by the drill.
  1. Observe the move buttons next. Holding a move button keeps sending that move to the other phones; if it stops arriving for 2 seconds, they drop it. [1] Record what happens on the receiving phone without treating this behavior alone as a defined pass or fail test.
  1. Observe STOP on its own. STOP releases every held direction on every phone and shows a full-screen alert to everyone else. [1] Record the observed response and assess it against the criteria set before the drill.
  1. Observe HOLD and SLOW apart from STOP. HOLD and SLOW stay on for everyone in the jobsite and are cleared when the last person leaves. [1] Record how each signal behaves during the drill.
  1. Include voice in the drill. Anyone who joins can take part in a voice call run from the phone browser. [1] Assess spoken calls using the criteria agreed before the exercise.
  1. Check the phone used for the drill. On Android browsers, signals such as STOP make the phone buzz; iPhone Safari ignores the buzz. [1]
  1. Close the drill and write the observations down before the next trainee. A jobsite link stops working 12 hours after the first person joins it. [1] A jobsite with nobody in it is wiped after 3 idle hours. [1] Check whether the existing session and link are still available before the next exercise.

Tools that can do it

OperatorLink is made by the team that publishes this site. It shows STOP, HOLD and SLOW to the jobsite crew and passes button presses, chat and voice between phones in a phone browser. [1] [1] Nobody needs to install an app, because the page runs in a browser. [1] The person who starts a jobsite shares a link or QR code, and the crew joins from it. [1] One-tap radio-style calls such as Go Ahead, Copy That and All Clear are sent as chat messages. [1]

A phone video call app is another possibility to assess. Check whether the call stays open for a whole drill, whether the trainer can see the trainee's hands while the call is made, and whether the phone keeps the screen awake through a lift.

A two-way radio is another possibility to assess. Check that the crew agrees on plain voice for each call, that the trainee can be heard over machine noise, and that the channel stays clear through the lift.

Match the option to the crew, the site and the assessment criteria. Check how each option supports the calls that need to be assessed.

Common mistakes to avoid

Ignoring the receiving phone: holding a move button keeps sending that move to the other phones, and if it stops arriving for 2 seconds, the other phones drop it. [1] Record the observed behavior without assuming that the press alone proves the whole call was clear.

Treating HOLD and SLOW as momentary: they stay on for everyone in the jobsite and are cleared when the last person leaves. [1] Make sure the assessment accounts for how these signals remain active.

Assuming every phone alerts the same way: on Android browsers, signals such as STOP make the phone buzz; iPhone Safari ignores the buzz. [1]

Reusing an old practice link: a jobsite link stops working 12 hours after the first person joins it. [1] Check that the link still works before starting the drill.

Leaving the session sitting empty between trainees: a jobsite with nobody in it is wiped after 3 idle hours. [1]

Treating STOP like an ordinary call: STOP releases every held direction on every phone and shows a full-screen alert to everyone else. [1] Record the observed response without treating an unapproved pass rule as part of the product's behavior.

Skipping home-screen setup: the app can be added to a phone's home screen as a standalone app. [1]

Frequently asked questions

Is OperatorLink free for crane signal trainers?

OperatorLink is currently free to use, and no paid plan is built yet. [1] Button presses, chat and voice pass between phones in a browser. [1] Before using it for a training session, check that the browser-based calls cover the actions the assessment needs to observe.

How does a trainer score a trainee's STOP call?

STOP releases every held direction on every phone and shows a full-screen alert to everyone else. [1] Record what happens during the drill and compare the observation with the assessment criteria established beforehand. The product describes the signal behavior but does not define a trainee pass score.

Do STOP signals buzz on every phone during a drill?

On Android browsers, signals such as STOP make the phone buzz; iPhone Safari ignores the buzz. [1] Include this difference when planning the drill and note which phone is being used for each observation.

How long does a trainee's practice link stay open?

A jobsite link stops working 12 hours after the first person joins it. [1] A jobsite with nobody in it is wiped after 3 idle hours. [1] Check the link and session before the next group starts, and share a new link or QR code if needed.

Can OperatorLink carry the trainer's voice during a drill?

Anyone who joins the jobsite can take part in a voice call run from the phone browser. [1] One-tap radio-style calls such as Go Ahead, Copy That and All Clear are sent as chat messages. [1] Use the assessment criteria to decide which spoken and written calls need to be observed during the drill.

OperatorLink is currently free to use, and no paid plan is built yet. [1]

Try OperatorLink

Sources

  1. OperatorLink's own description of itself (the product of this site's publisher)

Related comparisons